9 Essential Elements for Success in Product Management

In partnership with

TL;DR: Product management is more than just following a framework—it’s about resourcefulness, collaboration, and using the right ingredients effectively. A strong product vision inspires teams, while a clear strategy helps prioritize efforts and avoid decision paralysis. Product goals bridge long-term vision with daily execution, and a well-defined business model ensures alignment between product, customers, and revenue. A compelling value proposition connects the product to customer needs, while naming and testing assumptions prevents wasted effort on unvalidated ideas. Learning from failures fosters resilience and growth, and measuring outcomes with leading metrics enables continuous improvement. Teams often get caught up in perfecting frameworks, but real progress comes from taking small, actionable steps—identifying gaps, focusing on key elements, and iterating toward meaningful impact.

Product management is like cooking. You can follow a Michelin Star Chef's recipe exactly, but the result might not be what you expect. Why? Because cooking isn't just about the recipe. It's about technique, ingredients, and your personal touch.

Similarly, product management isn't just about frameworks and processes. It's about collaboration, resourcefulness, and achieving the best possible outcome with what you have.

The product manager, like the Chef, significantly influences the result. Your approach to product management is as crucial as having the right tools. However, without the necessary ingredients, your chances of success decrease dramatically.

This article will explore the core "ingredients" that drive progress in product management. We'll focus on understanding their essence and how they contribute to success, intentionally avoiding a deep dive into specific frameworks.

Over the years, I've seen teams get too caught up in implementing frameworks perfectly, losing sight of actual progress. The goal here is to avoid that trap and focus on the fundamentals.

Let's begin by exploring these key ingredients.

Learn how to make AI work for you

AI won’t take your job, but a person using AI might. That’s why 1,000,000+ professionals read The Rundown AI – the free newsletter that keeps you updated on the latest AI news and teaches you how to use it in just 5 minutes a day.

Sign up to start learning.

Recognizing the Right Ingredients

The fundamental ingredients are:

1. Product Vision → Inspire your team with a bold mission that motivates everyone to work towards a common goal.

2. Product Strategy → Outline the constraints and guidelines needed to achieve your vision effectively.

3. Product Goal → Establish short-term objectives to maintain focus and drive progress.

4. Business Model → Clarify the dynamics of your business, including how it operates and generates revenue.

5. Value Proposition → Understand your customers' needs and demonstrate how your product or service adds value to their lives.

6. Naming Assumptions → Identify gaps in your knowledge by pinpointing what you don’t know about your product or market.

7. Testing Assumptions → Prioritize the most critical assumptions and conduct tests to validate them.

8. Learning from Failures → Embrace small failures as opportunities to gain insights and improve your approach.

9. Measuring Outcomes → Continuously assess how your outputs contribute to delivering value and achieving goals.

It’s common to feel frustrated when many key elements are missing from your product management process. While it may seem overwhelming, staying in this situation is a choice you can change.

If you’re unsure where to start, consider tackling assumptions first. This approach is practical for product teams, even if you lack the authority of a Chief Product Officer or Product Director. By naming, testing, and sharing insights from assumptions, you can foster essential conversations that will help implement other critical aspects over time.

Now that you’re familiar with these fundamental ingredients, let’s delve into each one at a high level. This will help you understand their purpose and how they can benefit your product management efforts.

1. Product Vision

I often notice confusion between a company's mission, vision, and its product vision. When mentoring product professionals, I’m frequently asked whether they are the same. Let me simplify it for you.

A company's mission defines its purpose—why it exists—while its vision describes its long-term goals. In contrast, a product vision is more specific, outlining where the product should be in three to five years.

For startups, the company and product vision are often the same since there’s only one product. However, as a company expands and develops multiple products, having a distinct company vision alongside multiple product visions becomes essential.

Before diving deeper into product vision, let me ask you a few questions:

• Do you understand why your work on the product matters?

• Are you working toward something you truly care about?

• Can you connect your daily tasks to a bigger vision?

If you find it difficult to answer “yes” to these questions, you might be missing a strong product vision.

A well-defined product vision unites and inspires teams, giving them a sense of purpose and direction. Without it, teams can lose focus, uncertain about what they are striving for.

Crafting a compelling product vision can be challenging—it requires alignment, collaboration, and making tough choices about priorities. However, a great vision should be clear, bold, achievable, and inspiring—something that sticks in people’s minds and fuels progress.

2. Product Strategy

Knowing what to prioritize—and what to ignore—is crucial when building products. With so many options, teams can become overwhelmed, leading to stagnation. A well-defined product strategy streamlines decision-making and keeps teams focused.

Throughout my experience working with different companies, one common challenge repeatedly slowed us down: complex decision-making. I recall endless debates about whether to enhance the experience for existing customers or pursue new growth opportunities. Time and again, we faced the same dilemma, struggling to align on the next step. My biggest takeaway?

When everything is a priority, nothing gets done.

A strong product strategy eliminates this chaos by addressing key questions:

• Why? – Provide context for the strategy and link it to the product vision.

• Who? – Define your target audience and who you are intentionally not serving.

• What? – Clarify what you aim to achieve and what is deliberately excluded.

• How long? – Set a timeframe to guide decision-making.

You might be wondering how to put this into practice. A simple way to start is by listing bullet points for each of these areas. The format of your product strategy matters less than its substance.

To illustrate, here’s an example from an e-commerce company I worked with. Our strategy for Q1 was:

• Due to investor pressure to prove market fit, we must prioritize growth, even at the cost of higher customer acquisition expenses.

• Unlike last year’s focus on high-end customers, we are now expanding to a mid-range audience.

• The main goal is to acquire new customers while maintaining our current Net Promoter Score (NPS).

• We aim to accelerate growth by 20% compared to the same period last year.

At first glance, this strategy may seem too simple. I thought so too—but that’s the point. It provides clear guidance on what matters most and what can be deprioritized. Every team knew exactly where to focus their efforts.

A product strategy doesn’t need to be elaborate; it needs to be sharp. The ultimate goal? Empowered decision-making.

3. Product Goals

One of the biggest challenges teams face is deciding what to focus on next. There are always more opportunities than the capacity to execute them, and choosing the right path—while staying aligned with vision and strategy—can feel overwhelming.

A common but flawed approach is to divide and conquer by assigning unrelated tasks across the team, hoping that progress will emerge organically. Unfortunately, this often leads to excessive context switching, reduced productivity, and a lack of motivation.

To stay effective, teams need to operate at different levels of focus:

• Vision defines the long-term destination (3–5 years).

• Strategy provides short-term direction and context.

• Product goals bridge the gap between vision and daily execution.

Without clear product goals, teams may struggle to determine their next steps, even with a strong vision and strategy in place.

While some may associate product goals with Scrum, I believe they apply regardless of the development methodology. A well-defined product goal helps teams focus for four to six weeks, making progress toward the larger vision.

For example, in my previous e-commerce experience, one of our initial product goals was:

“Satisfied customers can bring their friends to our platform for a reward.”

This goal didn’t dictate a specific solution but established a clear direction and audience. We aimed to introduce a referral program for our most satisfied customers while experimenting with different reward types. Setting this goal for six weeks gave the team clarity and focus.

Before defining product goals, we often felt like dogs chasing their tails—constantly busy but getting nowhere. A strong product goal changed that, connecting our daily efforts to meaningful progress.

4. Business Model

Understanding the business dynamics of product teams is crucial. Without it, teams risk falling into the same anti-patterns I mentioned earlier. Stick with me, and I'll explain why this matters.

In traditional business structures, product teams simply serve the business—receiving requirements and executing them without question. This approach may have worked in the past, but it’s ineffective today and unlikely to succeed in the future.

In contrast, modern product teams—especially in startups—are responsible for the full product lifecycle. They must:

• Identify the right opportunities to pursue

• Decide what to deprioritize

• Deliver on the business value proposition

None of this is possible without a deep understanding of how the business operates.

Here’s the reality:

• Product teams working in isolation fail.

• Product teams treated as service providers fail.

• Without strong collaboration between product and business stakeholders, everyone fails.

A well-defined business model connects the dots between products, business, and customers—leading to better decisions and a higher chance of creating value faster.

Surprisingly, many product teams have never even seen the business model of the product they work on. I often hear product managers say:

"We don’t have time."
"The business team isn’t supporting us."

Let me be blunt: Complaining changes nothing. Taking action changes everything.

The good news? You don’t need a 50-page business plan filled with speculative spreadsheets. We’ve moved past that. The only certainty is uncertainty, so a flexible approach is key.

Lean Canvas or Business Model Canvas are simple yet powerful tools that can bring the clarity you need. The goal is to:

1. Get product and business teams in the same room to craft or refine the business model.

2. If business stakeholders don’t engage, create the business model yourself and share it with them.

3. Insist on collaboration, but if they don’t respond, assume alignment and move forward.

I guarantee that if you send them a business model draft and suggest improvements, you’ll get a response—probably within five minutes.

5. Value Proposition

How easily can you connect your product to your customers' tasks, pains, and gains?

If you struggle to answer this, stop everything and fix it—immediately. Understanding this will simplify your work and prevent costly missteps.

Every product should empower users and help them succeed. To achieve that, you need to deeply understand your audience. That’s where the Value Proposition Canvas comes in. It’s a simple yet powerful tool to align your product with customer needs.

Here’s how it works:

1. Start with your customers. Identify:

   • Tasks: What are they trying to accomplish?

   • Pains: What challenges or frustrations do they face?

   • Gains: What benefits or improvements do they expect?

2. Evaluate your product. Determine how it:

   • Relieves pains

   • Creates gains

Using this framework, we were able to adapt our product to fit our customers' real-world needs—and as a result, our business began to grow.

When you create your own Value Proposition Canvas, you’ll quickly spot misalignments and gain clarity on what needs improvement. The outcome? A product that genuinely enhances users' lives—and a business that thrives.

6. Naming Assumptions

In life, I see two extremes: over-optimism and over-pessimism—both equally dangerous.

• The overly optimistic assume everything will go as planned, ignoring potential risks.

• The overly pessimistic fear failure so much that they avoid taking risks altogether.

The result? One moves fast but encounters major setbacks, while the other stays stuck.

When working with digital products, you’ll always have assumptions. Ignoring them entirely leads to unpleasant surprises. Instead, the key is to:

• Acknowledge assumptions

• Discuss them openly

• Decide which ones to test and which to ignore

The Power of Naming Assumptions

One of the best things about assumptions is that you don’t need a product vision, strategy, or product goals to start identifying them. Simply acknowledging them is a powerful step toward helping your team grow.

When I consult with feature factory companies, my first piece of advice is:

Start naming assumptions, testing them, and learning from real evidence.

A Simple Exercise to Identify Assumptions

1. Identify Assumptions

   • Gather your product team and ask:

     • “What are we assuming behind this feature?”

     • Examples:

       • Customers will solve problem X with this feature.

       • Customers will upgrade their subscription because of this feature.

2. Assess Evidence

   • On a scale from 1 to 5, rate the strength of evidence behind each assumption:

     • 1 = No evidence

     • 5 = Strong evidence (safe to proceed without further testing)

Why This Works

This simple exercise quickly reveals what you don’t know—allowing you to run experiments, gather evidence, and make smarter decisions before investing in delivery.

Instead of blindly building features, you validate what truly matters—reducing waste and increasing impact.

7. Testing Assumptions

Identifying assumptions is crucial—but meaningless unless you test them. However, here’s where many teams fall into a trap:

1. Testing everything – This is inefficient and overwhelming.

2. Avoiding tests due to "enough" evidence – Not all evidence is created equal.

Instead, focus only on testing critical assumptions—those that:

• Could make or break your initiative

• Lack strong supporting evidence

Understanding Evidence Strength

• Weak evidence: A customer saying, “I would buy this.”

• Strong evidence: A customer paying upfront to access an early version.

The key to assumption testing is starting small and scaling gradually based on evidence. Your first experiments should provide direction, and later tests should refine solutions.

Example: Testing a Blog Feature

Let’s assume you believe customers would engage with a blog within your product. Here’s a scalable testing strategy:

1. 404 Test (Weak Evidence)

• Add a blog link to your navigation for 1% of users for two hours.

• Track the click-through rate (CTR).

• If >5% click, move to the next step.

• Fast setup (few hours) but weak evidence.

2. Landing Page (Moderate Evidence)

• Create a page stating: “We’re working on a blog. Sign up to stay updated.”

• Track email signups (a stronger signal of interest).

• A/B test different messaging.

• Takes a few days but provides better evidence.

3. Customer Interviews (Moderate Evidence)

• Reach out to 6–8 people who signed up.

• Understand why they want a blog and what content would be valuable.

• Provides deeper insights but requires effort.

Scaling Further

Based on your learnings, you can:

• Prototype content to measure engagement.

• Offer a pre-launch discount to see if users would pay.

• Build the full feature only when evidence is strong.

Here’s Why Over 4 Million Professionals Read Morning Brew

• Business news explained in plain English

• Straight facts, zero fluff, & plenty of puns

• 100% free

See for yourself

8. Learning from Failures

Building digital products isn’t always exciting. Sometimes, after hitting the wall repeatedly, you just want to give up. I get it—it’s tough to keep pushing forward when success feels out of reach, and failure seems like the only outcome.

But here’s the truth: Product management is about resilience.

• You’ll likely fail ten times before you succeed.

• The key isn’t avoiding failure—it’s learning from it.

Great product teams embrace failure as a learning tool. They don’t expect every experiment to work, but they know each failed attempt brings insights that lead to success.

Instead of seeing failures as setbacks, ask:

• What did we learn?

• What should we do differently next time?

• How can we turn this into an advantage?

The real magic? Not giving up. Keep moving, keep iterating, and success will follow.

9. Measuring Outcomes

Product teams aim to maximize value, which makes measuring outcomes essential. However, teams often fall into the trap of focusing solely on outputs rather than meaningful results.

Consider an example where the desired outcome is a 10% revenue increase compared to the previous year. Measuring this alone presents a challenge. If revenue is the only focus, by the time you realize you have missed the target, it is often too late to take corrective action.

To address this, it is important to differentiate between laggard and leading metrics. Revenue is a laggard metric because it takes time to measure and respond to. Leading metrics, on the other hand, provide quick and actionable insights. To identify these, start with a laggard metric and ask, "What contributes to this result?"

For an e-commerce business, possible leading metrics include:

• Customers successfully finding products they are searching for

• Recommended products leading to increased cart additions

• Fewer steps from landing on the site to completing a purchase

• Lower product return rates

By focusing on leading metrics, teams can iterate faster and make improvements that drive the desired outcome.

This approach is used by companies like Amazon, which distinguishes between input and output metrics. Input metrics, such as ensuring products are in stock, are directly controllable. Output metrics, like stock market performance, are influenced but cannot be controlled.

To measure outcomes effectively, teams should start small. Identify a small, impactful change, track its results, and iterate based on the findings. Constraints exist, but they should not prevent progress. Instead, they should guide smarter, more informed decision-making.

Key Takeaways

• Begin with a straightforward approach to your product strategy, discovery, and delivery. Avoid jumping into complex frameworks right away, as this can divert your attention from collaboration and progress.

• Recognize that product strategy, discovery, and delivery are not isolated stages; they are deeply connected. Each element supports the others, and a deficiency in one area can hinder overall value creation.

• When facing multiple gaps, introduce one new element at a time. Small adjustments are more manageable than attempting a complete overhaul. For instance, if you're stuck in a feature factory mindset, start by identifying and testing your assumptions. This will help clarify why certain features may not be worth pursuing.

• Engage with organizations at their current level rather than trying to push them far ahead. Focus on identifying the smallest actionable steps you can take today to improve future outcomes. Keep your end goal in mind, but prioritize the process of getting there.